tool

Unfair dismissal

Unfair dismissal occurs when an employment is terminated without a valid reason or without a fair process, as defined under Australian employment law.

What is unfair dismissal?

Unfair dismissal refers to a situation where an employee’s termination is harsh, unjust or unreasonable under the Fair Work Act. This can relate to the reason for dismissal, the process followed, or both.

In Australia, eligible employees can challenge a dismissal through the Fair Work Commission. Employers must show that a valid reason existed and that procedural fairness was followed, including giving the employee an opportunity to respond.

Things to know

  • Unfair dismissal claims are assessed by the Fair Work Commission.
  • Both the reason for dismissal and the process followed by the employer may be considered.
  • Performance, conduct or operational reasons can potentially lead to dismissal if handled appropriately.
  • Poor documentation can make it more difficult for employers to demonstrate that a dismissal was fair.
  • Eligibility requirements apply before an employee can make an unfair dismissal claim.

FAQs

What makes a dismissal unfair?

A dismissal may be considered unfair if there is no valid reason for ending employment or if the employer does not follow a fair and reasonable process before making the decision.

Who can make an unfair dismissal claim?

Eligibility depends on factors such as length of service, employment status and whether the employer falls within Australia's national workplace relations system.

Can an employee be dismissed for poor performance?

Yes. However, employers should communicate concerns clearly, provide appropriate support and allow employees an opportunity to improve before dismissal is considered.

Does a fair process matter if there is a valid reason for dismissal?

Yes. A valid reason alone may not be sufficient if the dismissal process is not conducted fairly.

How can employers reduce unfair dismissal risk?

Clear workplace policies, consistent performance management practices, thorough documentation and fair decision-making processes can help reduce risk.

ADP Lyric HCM

ADP Lyric HCM

Say goodbye to HR headaches with ADP Lyric HCM, your all-in-one solution that seamlessly unites payroll, HR and workforce management.

Discover ADP Lyric HCM

Related resources

insight

Notice Periods: What You Need to Know

insight

Confessions of a wage underpayment

guidebook

Avoid Fair Work record keeping penalties